The last backend piece: when the agent hits a decision only the operator can
make, it surfaces a structured question instead of guessing or stalling.
- ask_operator(prompt, why?, options?, context_entities?): nomos-local tool
that records a session_questions row, moves the task to awaiting_input, emits
question.raised, and ENDS the turn (the agent loop returns after it, so the
agent can't barrel past its own question). The prompt becomes the assistant's
visible message so the question also shows inline in the transcript.
- Two resume paths, both close the question + emit question.answered + return
the task to executing:
- Panel: POST /sessions/{id}/questions/{qid}/answer → resumes the agent in the
background with the answer injected (reusing the continuation machinery,
refactored continueSession → resumeSession). Returns 202; the reply lands via
message polling.
- Chat reply: the next chat message on a task with an open question IS the
answer — auto-closed in handleChat; the turn itself is the resume.
Verified end-to-end: forcing a decision paused the task at awaiting_input with
the structured question (prompt/why/options/entities); a panel answer resumed
the agent (it acknowledged host:strong and continued); a plain chat reply
auto-closed a second question. Cleanup + tests green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Operator: "I'd like to be able to see in the chat what the agent is actually
running, right now I just wait while nothing happens." Two compounding gaps:
1. The auto-continuation worker (cmd/nomos/continue.go) had zero live push —
its result only appeared on a manual page reload, so approving a plan and
watching the chat looked completely dead even while the agent was actively
working.
2. Even with polling, continueSession only persisted ONE message at the very
end of a continuation — a continuation that runs several tool calls before
concluding would still show total silence for however long that took.
Fixed both:
- web/src/lib/stores/chat.ts: polls the current session's messages every 3s
between turns (never while a live stream owns the message list) and merges
in anything new. Started after a live turn ends and when a session loads;
stopped on new-chat/session-switch.
- cmd/nomos/store.go: insertMessageReturningID/updateMessage — lets a message
be created as a placeholder and updated in place.
- cmd/nomos/continue.go: continueSession now inserts a placeholder the
instant it starts (renders as the existing "thinking" dots — immediate
feedback that something is happening) and updates that SAME row after
EVERY tool call, not just at the end. A poll within ~3s of any tool call
landing shows it — individual `run` commands appear as the agent issues
them, not just the final rolled-up summary.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Verified live: the new auto-continuation worker (previous commit) worked end
to end for the happy path (provision -> auto-verify -> report success, zero
operator ticks). But testing a failure-recovery case (a destroy that failed
because the container was still running) surfaced a real bug: continueSession's
emit closure only captured "text" events, so when chatWith ended the turn on
an "error" event (LLM returned an empty/refusal response, internal retry also
empty), the worker persisted a completely blank, uninformative "auto" message
— no sign anything had gone wrong, undermining observability of the very
mechanism just built.
- Capture "error" events and, if the turn produced no text/tool_calls at all,
persist an explanatory placeholder instead of blank.
- Add one outer retry of the whole chatWith call when the first attempt
produces nothing — the principle behind this whole feature ("don't give up
on the first error") should apply to the continuation mechanism itself, not
just the homelab commands it's continuing.
Also verified live: recovery-from-failure works via the normal chat path once
prompted, and cleaned up the test container.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The root cause behind "the agent stops at the first error and doesn't recover":
provisioning executions run ASYNCHRONOUSLY (pct_create fires the SSH work in a
goroutine and returns "running" immediately), so the agent's turn ENDS before
the result exists. The agent literally isn't running when the step fails — it
can't react to a failure it never observes. The only thing that fed results
back was the operator typing "continue" after every async step: the human was
the event loop. (In the flagged 18-message session the operator typed
continue/proceed/?? eight times while the agent correctly diagnosed each failure
but couldn't advance a step on its own.)
This makes the system the event loop instead:
- migrations/017: nomos_plan_executions links each gated execution to the chat
session that started it.
- cmd/nomos: after a tool result, any "execution <uuid>" it started is linked
to the session. A background worker (continue.go) polls for those executions
reaching a terminal state and — while the agent has an open assent window (an
approved plan is in flight) — re-invokes the agent with the result
("execution X completed/failed: <result>"), so it proceeds to the next step
or diagnoses+fixes the failure, with no operator tick. Guarded against loops
(mark-continued before running) and bounded by the 30-min window.
- chatWith(): chat() variant that injects the finished-execution note after
replayed history without persisting a fake user turn.
- DecideApproval: approving a step by ANY route (button or chat-assent) now
opens the assent window, so auto-continuation works regardless of how the
operator approved — previously only typing "go ahead" opened it.
- SOUL: the agent is told it will be auto-re-invoked when async steps finish —
don't poll get_execution_status, don't wait for "continue"; end the turn and
keep going step by step until the goal is verified or a genuine blocker.
This is the root fix, not another per-command patch: you can't enumerate every
failure of an unbounded action space, but you can give the agent a loop that
observes each result and adapts — because "do anything" always includes "the
first attempt failed."
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
