MVP M8: background detection — assumptions, risks, inconsistencies

The editor now runs Socrates' three Phase-0-validated detection prompts
against the live model, persists the findings, and surfaces them in a
new FindingsPanel beside the IssuesPanel. Click any finding to focus its
linked element across rail + diagram. Re-detect after model edits to
refresh against the new state.

apps/web/lib/llm/prompts/socrates
- detect-assumptions.md / detect-risks.md / detect-inconsistencies.md
  promoted verbatim from phase-0 (Phase 0 corpus validated them 10/10).

apps/web/lib/llm/detect.ts
- Three sequential detection passes (parallel was OOM-prone on 4B local
  models — Phase 0 lesson). Each pass uses the Phase 0 JSON schema with
  jsonObjectMode fallback + chatJSON repair-retry. Fail-soft per pass:
  one busted pass returns [] rather than blowing up the whole detect.
- post-validate strips hallucinated element refs (drops findings whose
  refs ALL fail to resolve; keeps findings with zero refs since some
  inconsistencies are genuinely about absences).

apps/web/prisma/schema.prisma
- Finding table: kind / text / linkedElementIds (JSON) / confidence /
  severity / validationCode / status / modelVersion / provider / model.
- ResearchFinding table reserved for the Tavily integration that comes
  next — schema in place so we don't have to migrate again.

apps/web/lib/db/repo.ts
- listOpenFindings(projectId), replaceFindings(...) — replaceFindings
  wipes prior open findings in a transaction and writes the new set so
  re-detect doesn't accumulate stale findings.

apps/web/app/api/projects/[projectId]/findings/route.ts
- GET returns persisted open findings.
- POST runs detect, persists, returns findings + meta (provider, model,
  durationMs, strippedRefs, droppedFindings).

apps/web/components/editor/FindingsPanel.tsx
- New panel, anchored bottom-right just left of IssuesPanel. Shows
  count summary (asm / risk / inc), detect / re-detect button, list
  grouped by kind (inconsistencies first, then risks, then assumptions),
  per-finding glyph + tag + severity + confidence + linked refs.
- Click a finding row → focus its first linked element via the same
  setFocusBlockId path the rail and IssuesPanel already use.
- "stale" indicator when the model version has advanced past the one the
  findings were detected against.

EditorShell wires version + projectId through to FindingsPanel.

Smoke-tested end-to-end: 12 findings returned (5 asm / 4 risk / 3 inc),
0 hallucinated refs stripped, ~37s on local gemma-4-e4b. Sample
assumption "students are willing to engage with an AI tutor that is
programmed to refuse providing complete solutions" — specific to
Aristotle's refusal_policy, not a generic startup truism.

Deferred to follow-ups: inline rail/diagram badges from findings,
auto-detect-on-save, Tavily research, experiment modal.
This commit is contained in:
2026-04-30 00:43:27 +02:00
parent 4b8e3f04ee
commit 4e725c0b2b
10 changed files with 1010 additions and 1 deletions

View File

@@ -26,6 +26,7 @@ model Project {
snapshots ModelSnapshot[]
changes ChangelogEntry[]
threads SocratesThread[]
findings Finding[]
}
model ModelSnapshot {
@@ -87,3 +88,55 @@ model SocratesMessage {
@@index([threadId, createdAt])
}
/// Background-detected finding (assumption / risk / inconsistency).
/// Findings are scoped to the model version that produced them; on every
/// detection run we delete the project's previous open findings and write
/// the new set so we don't accumulate stale ones across model edits.
model Finding {
id String @id @default(cuid())
projectId String
/// "assumption" | "risk" | "inconsistency"
kind String
text String
/// JSON-encoded string[] of element ids this finding references.
linkedElementIds String
confidence Float
/// Risks only: "low" | "medium" | "high"
severity String?
/// Inconsistencies only: optional structural-rule code (S1, M2, T1, …)
validationCode String?
/// Lifecycle: "open" | "dismissed" | "resolved"
status String @default("open")
/// Model version this finding was detected against.
modelVersion Int
/// Provider + model that emitted the finding.
provider String?
llmModel String?
createdAt DateTime @default(now())
project Project @relation(fields: [projectId], references: [id], onDelete: Cascade)
research ResearchFinding[]
@@index([projectId, status])
@@index([projectId, kind])
}
/// Web research results from validating a finding via Tavily / similar.
/// Deferred to a follow-up commit; schema is here so we don't have to
/// migrate again later.
model ResearchFinding {
id String @id @default(cuid())
findingId String
query String
url String
title String?
snippet String?
/// "supports" | "contradicts" | "neutral"
stance String @default("neutral")
createdAt DateTime @default(now())
finding Finding @relation(fields: [findingId], references: [id], onDelete: Cascade)
@@index([findingId])
}